Record the identity and origin of the specimen exactly as received. Accurate identification links every observation in this form to a specific piece of material and helps avoid mix-ups between samples examined on the same day.
Sample/specimen ID
Batch, heat, melt or lot number
Project, order or work reference
Submitted by/requesting party
Date sample received
Date of examination
Specimen source
Raw material (as-received stock)
Production component
Failed or degraded part
Weldment or welded joint
Coating, cladding or surface layer
Reference or control coupon
Additively manufactured part
Other or unknown
Specimen location and orientation reference
Condition of the sample on receipt
Undamaged and complete
Minor surface damage or scratches
Previously cut or sectioned
Corroded, oxidised or contaminated
Deformed during transport
Other
Has the sample already been examined by another technique?
Attach the submission form, drawing extract or request documentation
The specimen identifiers match the accompanying documentation and are legible on the mounted specimen.
Describe the material as fully as the available information allows. Where the exact grade is unknown, record what is known and mark the rest as unverified so that later interpretation can be read in the right context.
Material designation or grade
Material family
Carbon steel
Low-alloy steel
Stainless steel (austenitic)
Stainless steel (ferritic)
Stainless steel (martensitic)
Stainless steel (duplex/precipitation-hardened)
Cast iron (grey, ductile or malleable)
Aluminium alloy
Copper or brass alloy
Nickel or cobalt alloy
Titanium alloy
Magnesium or zinc alloy
Powder-metallurgy product
Coating, braze or filler metal
Other or not yet determined
Nominal chemical composition (weight percentages, if known)
Is a chemical composition report available?
Product form
Plate or sheet
Strip or foil
Bar or rod
Tube or pipe
Wire
Forging
Casting
Fastener or machined part
Weld deposit
Additively manufactured part
Other or unknown
Supply or heat-treatment condition (as stated by the submitter)
As-received/as-manufactured (condition not stated)
Annealed
Normalised
Quenched
Quenched and tempered
Solution treated
Age hardened/precipitation hardened
Stress relieved
Hot worked
Cold worked
Case hardened or surface treated
Unknown
Nominal wall or section thickness (mm)
Was the material exposed to elevated temperature during service or testing?
Any additional material background relevant to interpretation
Sectioning can easily introduce heat, deformation or smeared material that later looks like a microstructural feature. Record how the specimen was removed and mounted so that preparation artefacts can be recognised during examination.
Sectioning method
Abrasive cut-off wheel (wet)
Abrasive cut-off wheel (dry)
Precision diamond wafering saw
Wire electrical discharge machining
Waterjet cutting
Bandsaw or hacksaw
Shearing or punching
Other
Cut-off wheel, blade or wire specification
Was a coolant or lubricant used during cutting?
Is there any evidence of cutting-induced deformation, heating or contamination?
Mounting method
Not mounted (held in a fixture or clamp)
Hot compression mounting with thermosetting resin
Hot compression mounting with thermoplastic resin
Cold mounting with epoxy resin
Cold mounting with acrylic resin
Conductive mounting material (for electron microscopy)
Electroless nickel plating for edge support
Other
Was edge retention an important consideration for this specimen?
Mount or specimen diameter (mm)
Was vacuum impregnation used to fill porosity or cracks?
The specimen orientation in the mount is recorded and marked on the mount.
Enter the full surface-preparation sequence. Each step should remove the damage introduced by the previous step; the final surface must be free of scratches, smearing and pull-out before etching or examination.
Surface preparation sequence log
Step no. | Abrasive or polishing surface | Grit or particle size | Lubricant or coolant | Duration (seconds) | Force or pressure applied | Notes (rotation, direction, observations) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Silicon carbide paper | P240 | Water | 90 | Light | Planar grinding, rotate specimen 90 degrees between steps | |
2 | Silicon carbide paper | P600 | Water | 90 | Light | Continue until previous scratches removed | |
3 | Diamond suspension on woven cloth | 6 µm | Water-based lubricant | 300 | Moderate | Final deformation removal before fine polishing | |
Final polishing method
Colloidal silica suspension
Alumina suspension (approximately 0.05 µm)
Alumina suspension (0.3 to 1 µm)
Diamond suspension (1 µm)
Diamond suspension (0.25 µm or finer)
Diamond paste on synthetic cloth
Vibratory polishing
Electropolishing
Chemical-mechanical polishing
Other
Final polishing duration (minutes)
Was vibratory or extended mechanical polishing used to obtain a deformation-free surface?
Was the polished surface inspected before etching to confirm it was free of preparation artefacts?
Cleaning performed after polishing
Rinsed with solvent only
Ultrasonic cleaning in solvent
Ultrasonic cleaning in water-based detergent
No cleaning performed
Other
Polishing continued until the surface appeared free of visible scratches under oblique illumination.
Etching reveals microstructural contrast by preferentially attacking certain phases, grain boundaries or orientations. Record the etchant and timing precisely, since over-etching can mask fine features and under-etching can hide grain boundaries.
Was the specimen etched to reveal microstructural contrast?
Etchant(s) used
Nital (nitric acid in alcohol)
Picral (picric acid in alcohol)
Aqua regia based solution
Murakami-type alkaline solution
Glyceregia-type solution
Vilella-type reagent
Kalling-type reagent
Marble-type reagent
Kroll-type reagent (fluoride based)
Hydrofluoric acid based solution
Electrolytic oxalic acid solution
Sodium hydroxide solution (electrolytic or immersion)
Tint or colour etchant
Other
Etchant concentration or composition
Etching time (seconds)
Was etching performed at ambient room temperature?
Etching technique
Immersion or swab etching
Electrolytic etching
Cathodic vacuum etching
Thermal etching in a controlled atmosphere
Plasma etching
Other
Was the specimen re-polished and re-etched during the examination?
Etching was stopped as soon as the structure became clearly visible in order to limit over-etching.
Microscope settings determine how reliably features can be resolved and measured. Record illumination mode, magnification and calibration so that any image produced from this examination can be interpreted consistently later.
Primary examination technique
Optical microscopy – bright-field illumination
Optical microscopy – dark-field illumination
Optical microscopy – differential interference contrast
Optical microscopy – polarised light
Digital or automated light microscope
Scanning electron microscopy
Other
Instrument identifier
Magnification used during examination
50×
100×
200×
250×
500×
1000×
1500×
2000×
5000×
10000× or higher
Objective lens and numerical aperture used for the principal images
Calibration reference used
Date of the most recent instrument calibration or verification
Was an image calibration or scale reference applied before capturing images?
Illumination or filter settings used
Standard white light, no filter
Blue contrast filter
Green or red filter
Polarising filter
Neutral density filter
Other or not recorded
Number of fields of view examined in total
Describe what is actually visible before drawing conclusions. Distinguish clearly between directly observed features and interpretations, and note whether features are representative or confined to isolated fields.
Overall microstructure classification (as observed)
Predominantly equiaxed ferrite
Ferrite with pearlite
Pearlite-dominated structure
Martensitic structure
Bainitic structure
Single-phase austenitic structure
Austenite with ferrite (mixed or duplex)
Austenite with carbide precipitates
Precipitation-hardened matrix with dispersed particles
Cast dendritic structure
Eutectic or eutectoid constituent
Deformed or elongated grains (worked structure)
Recrystallised structure
Partially transformed or mixed structure
Not yet classified
Estimated abundance of observed constituents
Absent | Trace (under 1%) | Minor (1 to 5%) | Moderate (5 to 20%) | Major (above 20%) | Not assessed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ferrite | ||||||
Pearlite or lamellar constituent | ||||||
Bainite | ||||||
Martensite | ||||||
Retained austenite | ||||||
Carbides or other precipitates | ||||||
Graphite | ||||||
Intermetallic or interdendritic phases |
Predominant phase constituents in plain language
Presence and distribution of notable microstructural features
Not observed | Rare or trace | Present in localised areas | Present in most fields examined | Dominant feature | Not assessed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Grain boundaries clearly resolved | ||||||
Prior-austenite grain boundaries visible | ||||||
Annealing or deformation twins | ||||||
Compositional banding or segregation | ||||||
Grain boundary precipitate films or networks | ||||||
Decarburised or depleted surface layer | ||||||
Surface scale, oxide or reaction layer | ||||||
Second-phase particles aligned with working direction |
Was quantitative image analysis performed?
Detailed description of the microstructure observed
Uniformity of the structure across the fields examined
Very non-uniform
Non-uniform
Moderately uniform
Uniform
Highly uniform
Not assessed
Grain size affects strength, toughness and formability and can indicate whether the expected thermal or mechanical processing took place. Record both the measurement method and the result, since different methods can give different numbers on the same specimen.
Grain size determination method
Visual comparison with reference charts
Planimetric (area counting) method
Linear intercept method
Image analysis software
Determined previously and reported by the submitter
Not determined
Mean grain size (µm)
Grain size index or class number (if a chart or index scale was used)
Grain size range (minimum to maximum)
Predominant grain shape
Equiaxed
Elongated in one direction
Columnar
Dendritic
Bimodal (mixed coarse and fine)
Irregular or interlocking
Not assessed
Was grain size measured in more than one specimen orientation?
Was abnormal or exaggerated grain growth observed?
Is there evidence of partial recrystallisation or mixed grain structure?
Inclusions are usually assessed on the polished, unetched surface. Their type, shape, size and distribution influence machinability, fatigue behaviour and fracture path, so record both what was seen and how it was rated.
Were non-metallic inclusions observed?
Inclusion types observed
Fine, rounded or globular particles
Elongated, stringer-like particles aligned with working direction
Angular, hard-looking particles
Glassy or silicate-like particles
Large, irregular exogenous particles
Film-like or network constituents
Porosity mistaken for inclusions (excluded)
Not identifiable by optical microscopy alone
Other
Inclusion distribution
Randomly and evenly distributed
Aligned in bands or stringers
Clustered or segregated locally
Concentrated at grain boundaries
Concentrated near the surface
Concentrated at the section centreline
Not assessed
Inclusion observation and rating log
Inclusion type or appearance | Rating method or chart used | Severity (1 = minimal, 5 = severe) | Observed size range | Field or location examined | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Elongated stringers | Visual comparison chart | 5 to 40 µm long | Central region, transverse section | Sparse, aligned with rolling direction | ||
Fine globular particles | Visual comparison chart | 2 to 8 µm diameter | Throughout | Fairly uniform distribution | ||
Was an inclusion rating performed against a published or internal reference chart?
Comments on inclusions and their possible effect on the material
Record all anomalies even if they appear minor. Note whether each feature is intrinsic to the material, related to processing, or produced during preparation, and describe its location and dimensions where possible.
Features observed in the examined sections
No significant defects observed
Round gas pores
Shrinkage or micro-shrinkage cavities
Cracks following grain boundaries
Cracks crossing grain interiors
Solidification or hot-cracking type fissures
Cold or delayed cracking features
Corrosion attack, pitting or crevice-type attack
Creep-like cavitation or voids on boundaries
Weld-related features (lack of fusion, undercut, coarse HAZ)
Seams, laps or folds on the surface
Decarburised or depleted surface layer
Carburised or enriched surface layer
Oxide scale or heat-tint layer
Quench cracking or quench-induced features
Widmanstatten or similarly acicular arrangement
Compositional banding or segregation
Cold shuts or casting laps
Not assessed
Other
Do the observed defects appear related to material processing rather than service?
Were the dimensions of the defects measured?
Could any observed feature be an artefact of specimen preparation?
Recommended additional examination
Scanning electron microscopy of the defect region
Chemical analysis at the defect (localised)
Micro-hardness traverse across the affected zone
Additional sections taken from the same specimen
Re-polishing and re-etching of the same surface
Macro-examination or fractography of the fracture surface
Chemical analysis of the bulk material
No further examination recommended
Other
Narrative description of defects and anomalies
Micro-hardness can help confirm whether the observed microstructure matches the stated condition and can reveal surface layers, softened zones or heat-affected regions. Complete this section only if hardness testing was carried out.
Was a hardness or micro-hardness test performed on the specimen?
Hardness test type
Vickers micro-indentation
Knoop micro-indentation
Vickers macro-indentation
Rockwell-type indentation
Other
Hardness measurement record
Location or distance from surface | Applied force | Hardness value | Scale or unit used | Notes (indent quality, phase under indent, cracking) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Surface, approx. 0.05 mm | 100 | 245 | HV0.1 | Indent well formed, small scatter | |
Sub-surface, approx. 0.5 mm | 100 | 288 | HV0.1 | Indent placed in matrix | |
Core | 100 | 292 | HV0.1 | Consistent with matrix value | |
Hardness trend or gradient observed
Do the hardness results appear consistent with the microstructure observed?
Images are the primary evidence supporting the written observations. Each image should be traceable to a location on the specimen and include a scale reference so that features can be re-measured later.
Image log
Image ID | Magnification used | Field or location on specimen | Etched surface? | Scale bar length (µm) | What the image shows | Image file | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
IMG-001 | 200× | Centre of section | Yes | 100 | Overview of the as-polished surface showing inclusion distribution | ||
IMG-002 | 500× | Near surface region | Yes | 50 | Etched surface showing grain structure and surface layer | ||
Upload the principal overview photomicrograph
Upload a higher magnification detail photomicrograph
Upload the complete image set, measurement export or supporting report
Do all captured images include a scale bar or magnification reference?
Image file names correspond to the image IDs listed in the image log.
Use this section to compare the observations with whatever reference information is available. Where no reference exists, state that clearly. Any comparison reflects the analyst's judgement based on the material examined and the information provided at the time.
Basis used for the assessment
Internal specification, drawing or work instruction
Customer or supplier requirement document
Published microstructural comparison charts
Previous examination records for similar material
General materials-engineering good practice guidance
No specific reference available
Other
Is the observed microstructure consistent with the stated heat-treatment or supply condition?
Analyst assessment of the examined characteristics
Poor | Fair | Good | Very good | Excellent | Not assessed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Microstructure type and constituent phases | ||||||
Grain size and morphology | ||||||
Inclusion content and distribution | ||||||
Freedom from defects and anomalies | ||||||
Surface layer condition | ||||||
Uniformity between fields examined |
Overall agreement between observations and the stated expectation
Strong disagreement
Disagreement
Neutral or unclear
Agreement
Strong agreement
No expectation stated
Limitations and uncertainties of this examination
Summarise the findings and state the basis of the conclusion. Conclusions are limited to the specimen examined and to the information available at the time of the examination.
Overall examination outcome
Microstructure appears consistent with the stated expectation
Microstructure broadly consistent, with observations worth noting
Microstructure questionable – further evaluation suggested
Microstructure not consistent with the stated expectation
Inconclusive – additional examination required
Analyst conclusion
Recommended actions
Accept as examined, no further action
Record observations and retain for future reference
Re-examine after additional preparation
Take further sections from the same component
Undertake supplementary testing (mechanical, chemical or environmental)
Review processing or heat-treatment parameters
Review or re-rate inclusions with a defined reference chart
Discuss findings with the material producer or supplier
Refer the findings to a design or engineering review
Other
Recommendations and, where relevant, suggested corrective actions
Is a follow-up examination or review required?
Analyst confidence in the conclusions drawn (self-assessment)
Complete this section to keep the examination record traceable. Signing indicates that the entry reflects the observations made on the specimen(s) examined; it does not guarantee results for other specimens, components or batches.
Analyst name
Analyst role or background (as stated by the analyst)
Examination date and time
Analyst signature
Was this record reviewed by a second person?
Reviewer signature
Report or record reference number
Date the record was completed
Storage location of the specimen after examination
The observations recorded here relate only to the specimen(s) examined and may not represent the whole component, batch or delivery.
I have checked this record for completeness and internal consistency.
Analysis for Metallographic Examination Form – Microstructure, Inclusions and Defect Record
Important Note:
This analysis provides strategic insights to help you get the most from your form's submission data for powerful follow-up actions and better outcomes.
AI-Generated Content: This template and its accompanying guidance are AI-generated to provide a practical starting point for your form-building needs. Please review and customise the content to ensure it is accurate, appropriate and suitable for your intended use.
This guide is provided for general informational and planning purposes only. It does not constitute professional, legal, financial, medical, employment, privacy, regulatory, or advice of any other kind, nor does it certify that this template is suitable or compliant for any particular jurisdiction or purpose.
Laws, regulations, industry practices and business requirements vary. You are responsible for reviewing and customising the template to suit your intended use and obtaining advice from appropriately qualified professionals where necessary.
Please delete this section before publishing your form. See our Terms of Service for further information.
This Metallographic Examination Form is a comprehensive, structured record designed to document the microscopic examination of metals and alloys. Its primary purpose is to capture every stage of the metallographic workflow—from sample receipt and material identification through sectioning, polishing, etching, microscopy, microstructural analysis, defect assessment, imaging and final conclusion—in a single, traceable record. The form is organised into thirteen clearly defined sections that mirror a logical laboratory sequence, which reduces the chance of omitting critical information and allows reviewers to follow the reasoning behind each finding.
One of the form's greatest strengths is its sequential organisation. Each section builds upon the previous one, moving from specimen identity to material description, then preparation details, equipment settings, observations, and finally assessment and conclusions. This mirrors the actual workflow of a metallographic examination and makes the form intuitive for the analyst to complete and for a reviewer to audit.
The form makes extensive use of conditional follow-up logic. For example, selecting Specimen source triggers context-specific follow-ups such as weld process details for weldments or failure descriptions for degraded parts. This branching approach collects relevant depth only when applicable, keeping the form efficient for routine examinations while capturing rich detail for complex cases.
The inclusion of tables for the surface preparation sequence, inclusion observation log, hardness measurements and image log allows structured, tabular data entry that is far more useful for trend analysis and comparison than free-text alone. The sample rows provided in the tables serve as helpful guidance for analysts unfamiliar with the expected format.
The form also incorporates checkboxes for verification—such as confirming specimen identifiers match documentation, that the polished surface was free of scratches, and that observations relate only to the specimen examined. These act as lightweight quality-control prompts embedded within the record.
Sample/specimen ID serves as the primary identifier linking every observation in the record to a specific piece of material. It is the foundation of traceability and prevents mix-ups when multiple specimens are examined in a single session.
Batch, heat, melt or lot number connects the examination to a specific production batch, which is useful when correlating microstructural findings with processing history or when tracing issues back to a production run.
Project, order or work reference ties the examination to a broader administrative context—such as a work order or engineering project—helping with scheduling, reporting and retrieval of the record.
Submitted by/requesting party records who initiated the examination request, which supports communication, follow-up queries and accountability for the scope of work.
Date sample received and Date of examination establish the timeline of handling, which may be relevant when assessing storage effects or when interpreting sample condition on receipt.
Specimen source categorises the origin of the material (raw stock, production component, failed part, weldment, coating, coupon or additive part). This context is essential for interpreting microstructural observations—for instance, a failed part may require different scrutiny than a routine quality-control coupon. The follow-up prompts for specific sources are well-targeted, requesting descriptive details only for the relevant case.
Specimen location and orientation reference captures where on the component the section was taken and in what direction, which is important for understanding whether the observed structure is representative of a specific region (e.g. near-surface vs. centreline, transverse vs. longitudinal).
Condition of the sample on receipt documents any pre-existing damage, corrosion or deformation. This is operationally significant because surface contamination or prior sectioning can limit what can be observed and may introduce preparation challenges.
Has the sample already been examined by another technique? captures complementary data—such as chemical composition or non-destructive testing results—that may contextualise the microstructural findings and reduce redundant work.
The file upload field for submission documentation and the checkbox confirming identifier legibility support traceability and administrative completeness.
Material designation or grade provides the material context needed to interpret the microstructure—for example, the expected phases in an austenitic stainless steel differ fundamentally from those in a medium-carbon steel. Recording this early ensures all subsequent observations are read in the correct material context.
Material family groups the alloy into broad categories (carbon steel, stainless steel variants, aluminium alloy, cast iron, etc.), which facilitates categorised record-keeping and enables targeted follow-up questions such as expected graphite form for cast irons or phase balance for duplex structures.
Nominal chemical composition and Is a chemical composition report available? capture quantitative composition data when it exists, allowing the analyst to correlate microstructural observations with the actual alloy content and to assess whether the structure is consistent with expectations for that composition.
Product form (plate, bar, tube, forging, casting, etc.) influences the expected microstructural features—castings may show dendritic structures while rolled plate may exhibit banded or elongated grain features.
Supply or heat-treatment condition is critical for evaluating whether the observed microstructure matches the stated condition. Follow-ups for age-hardening parameters and surface treatment details show thoughtful, context-aware design.
Nominal wall or section thickness provides dimensional context relevant to sectioning feasibility and to the representativeness of the observed features.
Was the material exposed to elevated temperature? and Any additional material background capture service history and special circumstances that may explain unusual microstructural features such as creep damage, oxidation or prior repair effects.
Sectioning method records how the specimen was cut. This is operationally important because abrasive cutting can introduce heat damage or deformation, and electrical discharge machining can create a recast layer—both of which may be mistaken for genuine microstructural features if not properly identified and documented.
Cut-off wheel, blade or wire specification and Was a coolant or lubricant used? capture further detail about the cutting conditions, supporting traceability and helping to assess whether cutting damage is likely.
Is there any evidence of cutting-induced deformation? prompts the analyst to assess the sectioned surface for preparation artefacts and to note remedial action, which strengthens the reliability of later observations.
Mounting method (hot compression, cold epoxy, conductive mount, electroless plating, etc.) is relevant because mounting can affect edge retention, and hot mounting may alter heat-sensitive surface layers.
Was edge retention an important consideration? and its follow-up capture the approach taken to preserve the specimen edge—a common challenge in metallography, especially when evaluating surface coatings or decarburised layers.
Mount or specimen diameter provides dimensional reference, while Was vacuum impregnation used? documents whether porosity or cracks were filled to improve edge integrity during polishing.
The checkbox confirming that specimen orientation in the mount is recorded and marked is a good practice prompt that aids later re-examination or re-imaging.
The Surface preparation sequence log table captures the step-by-step grinding and polishing protocol with columns for step number, abrasive, grit size, lubricant, duration, force and notes. This structured approach ensures that the full preparation history is documented and that any question about surface artefacts can be traced back to specific preparation steps.
Final polishing method records the last surface-finish step, which is directly relevant to whether the polished surface will reveal inclusions and fine phases clearly.
Final polishing duration, Was vibratory or extended mechanical polishing used? and the pre-etching inspection prompt with its result options (free of scratches, smearing, pull-out, etc.) collectively provide strong quality-assurance evidence for the specimen surface quality.
Cleaning performed after polishing documents how residues were removed before etching or examination, which can affect etching behaviour and surface appearance.
The checkbox regarding polishing under oblique illumination reinforces best practice in surface preparation.
Was the specimen etched to reveal microstructural contrast? is a key branching question—if the answer is no, the form captures the reason (e.g. inclusion assessment only, etching deferred), preserving context for readers who may wonder why grain boundaries are not visible.
Etchant(s) used offers a comprehensive list of common reagents (nital, picral, glyceregia-type, Kroll-type, electrolytic options, tint etchants, etc.) with targeted follow-ups for concentration and electrolytic parameters. This level of detail supports reproducibility.
Etchant concentration or composition, Etching time and Etching technique (immersion, electrolytic, thermal, plasma) collectively document the etching protocol precisely, since etching behaviour is highly sensitive to these parameters.
Was the specimen re-polished and re-etched? captures any iterative preparation, which is common when initial etching does not produce satisfactory contrast or when inclusions must be re-examined on a fresh surface.
The checkbox about stopping etching as soon as the structure becomes visible reinforces the practical guidance embedded in the form's introductory paragraph.
Primary examination technique (bright-field, dark-field, differential interference contrast, polarised light, or scanning electron microscopy) documents the illumination or imaging mode, which affects what features are visible and how they should be interpreted.
Instrument identifier provides traceability to a specific microscope or imaging system, supporting audit and instrument-maintenance records.
Magnification used during examination is essential for correlating observations with images and for later measurement of feature sizes.
Objective lens and numerical aperture, Calibration reference used, Date of most recent calibration and Image calibration value collectively establish the measurement traceability of any dimensions reported in the record.
Illumination or filter settings and Number of fields of view examined provide additional context on the thoroughness and optical conditions of the examination.
Overall microstructure classification (as observed) categorises the dominant structure (ferrite, martensite, austenite, dendritic, etc.) and includes targeted follow-ups for martensite morphology, phase balance and grain elongation direction. This structured classification facilitates comparison across multiple examinations and records.
The two matrix rating tables—one for estimated abundance of constituents (ferrite, pearlite, martensite, carbides, graphite, etc.) and one for notable features (grain boundaries, banding, surface layers, second-phase alignment)—provide a semi-quantitative summary that is far easier to scan and compare than narrative text alone.
Predominant phase constituents in plain language captures an accessible description that complements the structured ratings.
Was quantitative image analysis performed? and its follow-up document any measured parameters (volume fractions, grain size, porosity, coating thickness), adding quantitative rigour where available.
Detailed description of the microstructure observed is the central narrative field, allowing the analyst to describe morphology, distribution, uniformity and field-to-field variation in their own words.
Uniformity of the structure across the fields examined provides a quick visual rating that helps readers assess the representativeness of the observations.
Grain size determination method (visual comparison, planimetric, linear intercept, image analysis, previously reported, or not determined) documents the measurement approach, with follow-ups for chart references and software details.
Mean grain size, Grain size index or class number and Grain size range capture both a central value and spread, which is more informative than a single number.
Predominant grain shape (equiaxed, elongated, columnar, dendritic, bimodal, irregular) provides morphological context relevant to processing history and mechanical behaviour.
The questions on multiple orientations, abnormal grain growth and partial recrystallisation prompt the analyst to look for and record notable grain-size anomalies that may indicate processing issues.
Were non-metallic inclusions observed? is a foundational question—if none were seen, the form captures the basis for that assessment (limited fields examined, surface condition issues, etc.), ensuring transparency.
Inclusion types observed provides a morphological classification (globular, stringer, angular, glassy, exogenous, film-like) with a follow-up requesting identification of additional techniques needed when optical microscopy alone is insufficient.
Inclusion distribution (random, stringer, clustered, grain-boundary concentrated, surface concentrated) is important because distribution can differ significantly even when overall volume fraction is similar.
The Inclusion observation and rating log table with severity ratings, size ranges and locations provides a structured, repeatable record that can be compared across batches.
Was an inclusion rating performed against a reference chart? captures the standardisation basis, and Comments on inclusions and their possible effect allows the analyst to connect observations to practical implications.
Features observed in the examined sections offers a broad checklist of potential defects—gas pores, shrinkage cavities, intergranular and transgranular cracks, corrosion attack, creep cavitation, weld-related features, surface layers, quench cracking and more—with targeted follow-ups for the most consequential types.
Do the observed defects appear related to material processing rather than service? and its follow-up prompt the analyst to categorise the likely origin, which is valuable for root-cause analysis.
Were the dimensions of the defects measured? captures quantitative data when available, and Could any observed feature be an artefact? is a critical quality prompt that helps distinguish genuine defects from preparation artefacts.
Recommended additional examination and Narrative description of defects and anomalies close the loop by documenting both the findings and suggested next steps.
This optional section, clearly labelled as such, supports correlation between microstructure and mechanical properties. Was a hardness or micro-hardness test performed? gates the section, with a reason-prompt if testing was not done.
The Hardness measurement record table with location, applied force, hardness value, scale and notes is well-structured for recording traverse data.
Hardness trend or gradient observed and Do the hardness results appear consistent with the microstructure observed? encourage the analyst to cross-check mechanical data against structural findings.
The Image log table (image ID, magnification, location, etched status, scale bar length, description, and image upload) provides a comprehensive, traceable record linking each image to its provenance. Separate upload fields for the principal overview photomicrograph and higher magnification detail ensure key images are readily accessible.
Do all captured images include a scale bar? and the checkbox confirming file-name-to-log correspondence are excellent quality-control prompts for image management.
Basis used for the assessment records whether the comparison is against an internal specification, customer requirement, published charts or general good practice—with a follow-up for document identifiers. This transparency is important because the reliability of the assessment depends heavily on the reference used.
Is the observed microstructure consistent with the stated condition? prompts explicit comparison with expectations, and the matrix rating table for assessed characteristics (microstructure type, grain size, inclusions, defects, surface layers, uniformity) provides a structured scorecard.
Overall agreement rating and Limitations and uncertainties field encourage honest, transparent reporting of the boundaries of the examination.
Overall examination outcome provides a clear, categorical verdict with follow-ups for questionable or inconclusive cases that request the specific aspects needing resolution and recommended additional work.
Analyst conclusion is the narrative summary tying all observations together, and Recommended actions offers a structured list of possible follow-up measures.
Analyst confidence in the conclusions (star rating) adds a useful self-assessment dimension.
Analyst name, Examination date and time and Analyst signature establish accountability and traceability. The review by a second person question with reviewer name and signature fields supports a two-person review workflow where appropriate.
Storage location of the specimen after examination ensures the physical specimen can be retrieved for re-examination.
The final checkboxes reminding the analyst that observations relate only to the specimen examined and that the record has been checked for completeness are well-placed closing reminders.
This form will produce a rich, multi-dimensional dataset suitable for quality records, batch comparison and trend analysis. The structured fields (tables, ratings, checkboxes) support quantitative aggregation, while the narrative fields capture contextual nuance. Because the form collects detailed preparation parameters, equipment settings and analyst identity, the records are suitable for internal traceability and for reproducing the examination if needed. From a privacy standpoint, the form captures analyst names and signatures—identifiable personal data—which should be handled in accordance with the organisation's data-handling practices. The data collected is primarily technical rather than sensitive.
The form's logical sequencing and clear introductory paragraphs for each section help guide the analyst. The use of placeholder text with concrete examples (e.g. "SP-2025-0148-A", "Heat 4471B/Lot 22C") is excellent for reducing ambiguity. However, the form is lengthy—thirteen sections with numerous questions—so completion in a single sitting may be demanding. The conditional follow-ups help reduce unnecessary fields, but users unfamiliar with metallography may still feel overwhelmed. The table-based log sections are well-designed but require careful entry. Overall, the form strikes a good balance between thoroughness and structure, and the checkboxes serve as helpful quality gates without adding significant friction.
This Metallographic Examination Form is a well-engineered, comprehensive instrument that captures the full scope of a metallographic examination with appropriate granularity at each stage. Its strengths include logical workflow-aligned structure, intelligent conditional logic, structured table-based logs for preparation and observations, embedded quality-control prompts, and transparent treatment of limitations and uncertainties. The form collects data in a way that supports both narrative reporting and structured comparison across examinations. Areas for consideration include the overall form length, which may benefit from collapsible or expandable sections in a digital format to reduce perceived effort, and the potential addition of a brief completion-time estimate or progress indicator for analysts completing the form on screen. The comprehensive approach ensures that the resulting records are detailed, traceable and suitable for a wide range of metallographic evaluation purposes, from routine quality control to failure investigation.
Mandatory Question Analysis for Metallographic Examination Form – Microstructure, Inclusions and Defect Record
Important Note:
This section explains why certain fields in this form are marked as required and provides general guidance on how these requirements may support the collection of complete, accurate and relevant information.
Required fields and information-collection obligations may vary depending on your industry, jurisdiction, business operations and intended use of the form. A field marked as required in this template does not necessarily mean that collecting the information is legally mandatory.
Please review each required field to determine whether it is necessary, appropriate and lawful for your particular purpose. Consider applicable privacy, data protection, consent and industry-specific requirements, and consult an appropriately qualified legal, privacy or compliance professional where necessary.
Please delete this section before publishing your form. See our Terms of Service for further information.
Sample/specimen ID
Recommendation: Requiring this field ensures every observation recorded in the form is linked to a specific specimen, which is foundational for traceability and record-keeping. Without a unique identifier, it would be extremely difficult to retrieve, compare or audit the examination record at a later stage. The form creator should confirm that the ID format used aligns with their laboratory's existing specimen-tracking conventions.
Specimen source
Recommendation: Requiring this field establishes the material context early in the record, which directly influences how subsequent microstructural observations should be interpreted. For example, a failed component may warrant different scrutiny than a routine coupon. Making this mandatory ensures the reader understands the examination scope before reading the findings. Its necessity depends on the form creator's operational workflow, but it broadly supports clearer, more contextualised documentation.
Material designation or grade
Recommendation: Requiring this field ensures the analyst and any reviewer can evaluate the microstructure in the context of the material being examined. Expected phases, grain structures and defect types vary substantially by alloy family, so recording the designation supports meaningful interpretation and comparison. If the exact grade is unknown, the form's guidance to record what is known and mark the rest as unverified is helpful and should be retained.
Sectioning method
Recommendation: Requiring this field supports the identification of potential preparation artefacts. Different cutting methods can introduce heat damage, deformation or recast layers that may be mistaken for microstructural features. Documenting the method used allows later readers to distinguish genuine features from preparation effects. The form creator should confirm whether this level of detail aligns with their quality-assurance expectations.
Final polishing method
Recommendation: Requiring this field documents the last surface-preparation step, which directly influences whether inclusions, fine phases and grain boundaries are clearly visible. Different polishing methods can produce different levels of surface finish and may introduce or remove features. Recording the final method supports reproducibility and quality traceability of the specimen surface.
Was the specimen etched to reveal microstructural contrast?
Recommendation: Requiring this field is important because etching status fundamentally changes how the microstructure observations should be read. If the specimen was examined unetched, certain features (grain boundaries, phase contrast) will not be visible and the absence of such observations is expected rather than anomalous. Making this mandatory ensures the reader knows the examination conditions and prevents misinterpretation of missing observations. The follow-up capturing the reason for unetched examination further supports record completeness.
Primary examination technique
Recommendation: Requiring this field records the imaging or illumination mode used, which affects what features are visible and how images should be interpreted. Bright-field, dark-field, polarised light and electron imaging each reveal different aspects of microstructure. Capturing this mandatory ensures the observations and images can be properly contextualised and supports reproducibility if the examination is repeated.
Magnification used during examination
Recommendation: Requiring this field establishes the scale at which observations were made and images captured. Without magnification data, dimensions of features cannot be reliably interpreted and images lose much of their evidential value. This field broadly supports data completeness and the practical utility of the image record. The form creator should consider whether a multi-select approach (the field already supports multiple magnifications) aligns with their documentation style.
Overall microstructure classification (as observed)
Recommendation: Requiring this field provides a structured, categorical summary of the dominant microstructure, which facilitates quick review and comparison across examinations. It anchors the detailed narrative description that follows and supports operational processing of records—for example, filtering records by microstructure type during batch reviews. The necessity of this requirement depends on the form creator's need for structured, searchable records.
Detailed description of the microstructure observed
Recommendation: Requiring this narrative field ensures the analyst records their detailed observations in their own words, capturing nuance that structured fields alone cannot convey. It supports data completeness by ensuring that no examination record is left without a substantive description of what was seen. This field is particularly valuable for later reviews, audits or comparisons where the reasoning behind the conclusion needs to be understood.
Were non-metallic inclusions observed?
Recommendation: Requiring this field ensures that inclusion assessment is explicitly addressed—either by recording inclusions observed or by noting their absence along with the basis for that determination. This supports data completeness by preventing the section from being silently skipped. If the form creator's examination scope does not always include inclusion assessment, they may wish to consider whether a mandatory gate question or an optional field better suits their workflow.
Narrative description of defects and anomalies
Recommendation: Requiring this field ensures that any defects or anomalies observed during the examination are described in detail, including location, morphology and possible origin. Even when no significant defects are found, a brief statement confirming this supports record completeness and prevents ambiguity. This field is central to the practical value of the examination record for quality tracking and potential root-cause analysis.
Overall examination outcome
Recommendation: Requiring this field provides a clear, categorical conclusion that serves as the primary takeaway from the examination. It supports operational processing by enabling quick assessment of whether the microstructure is consistent with expectations and whether further action is needed. The follow-up prompts for questionable or inconclusive outcomes further strengthen the record. The form creator should confirm that the five available outcome categories adequately cover their examination scenarios.
Analyst conclusion
Recommendation: Requiring this field ensures the analyst documents their reasoning, not just their observations. It captures the significance of the findings and the basis for the overall outcome. This supports record-keeping completeness and helps reviewers understand the thought process behind the conclusions, which is valuable when the record is revisited months or years later.
Analyst name
Recommendation: Requiring this field establishes accountability and traceability—who performed the examination. It is a standard record-control practice that supports internal quality processes and enables follow-up queries. The form creator should consider their data-handling practices for personal information when storing these records.
Examination date and time
Recommendation: Requiring this field provides a timestamp for the examination, supporting chronological record-keeping and traceability. It helps establish when observations were made, which can be relevant when correlating with other records or when assessing sample condition over time. Accurate date-time recording broadly supports orderly documentation practices.
Analyst signature
Recommendation: Requiring this signature serves as a formal confirmation by the analyst that the recorded entries reflect their observations. It supports record integrity and accountability within the form creator's documentation workflow. The form's introductory paragraph appropriately notes that signing does not guarantee results for other specimens or batches, which is a helpful and transparent caveat.
The form currently designates approximately seventeen fields as mandatory across its thirteen sections, which is a reasonable proportion given the form's overall length and complexity. The mandatory fields are well-distributed and tend to focus on core identification (specimen ID, material grade), critical preparation and examination parameters (sectioning method, polishing method, etching status, technique, magnification), key observations (microstructure classification, description, inclusions, defects), conclusions (overall outcome, analyst conclusion) and record control (name, date, signature). This distribution ensures that no section is left entirely without required data, supporting record completeness.
Balancing data depth against completion rates: Given the form's considerable length, care should be taken to ensure that the mandatory set does not create excessive friction, particularly for routine examinations. The current selection appears well-judged—requiring only fields that are practically essential for a meaningful examination record—while leaving many descriptive and supplementary fields optional. Form creators may wish to monitor completion times and user feedback to confirm that the mandatory set does not discourage thoroughness.
Conditional logic considerations: The form already makes effective use of conditional follow-ups (e.g. for specimen source, etching, hardness testing). Additional conditional logic could potentially be applied to sections like micro-hardness, which is already marked as optional in the section heading. Where a mandatory question has a "no" branch with further questions (e.g. etching status, inclusions), the design ensures the record is complete regardless of the path taken—this is an effective pattern that should be maintained.
Mandatory field placement: The mandatory fields are logically placed within their respective sections rather than clustered at the beginning or end, which encourages the analyst to complete the form in workflow order. The record-control fields (name, date, signature) appearing at the end is appropriate, as these serve as a final confirmation step.
Observations on scope: The form creator may wish to periodically review whether all currently mandatory fields are truly necessary for every examination type. For instance, if the form is sometimes used for preliminary or partial examinations, the strict requirement for fields like Overall examination outcome or Analyst conclusion may occasionally create difficulty. A practical approach is to retain these as mandatory but include clear placeholder guidance (e.g. "preliminary observations—final conclusion pending further examination") in the field descriptions. Overall, the current mandatory field strategy supports robust, traceable record-keeping without overburdening the analyst.